Latest Construction Forum Topics:

  • As satellites are added and removed from the GPS system in the future, how does my GPS device system adapt? (4 posts)
  • Why do I have to wait 30 days to apply Thompsons water sealer to my new deck? (6 posts)
  • Need a new mattress - any advice? (9 posts)
  • Heating argument ;(? (5 posts)
  • DO these match? (6 posts)
  • Where can I find cheap modern/retro furniture? (7 posts)
  • wiring a celing fan and a light fixture I switched places whith each other.? (3 posts)
  • Living room decor? (7 posts)
  • polyurethane on a "wood" laminate floor?? (5 posts)
  • Contemporary Paint Color HELP!!!!? (4 posts)
  • Am I in a timewarp? (7 posts)
  • If I plug an outlet strip into a surge protector, will all of its outlets (including the RJ-11) be protected? (3 posts)
  • What color should I paint my room? (18 posts)
  • When I upgrade my propane tank from the old style P.O.L valve to the new acme type, will my heater still fit? (3 posts)
  • I just had a new liner and wedding cake stairs installed. The liner has large wrinkles around the stairs.? (2 posts)
  •  
    Author Message

    Horsewisperer

    Members


    Online status

    370 posts

    Location: Vatican
    Occupation: Pharmacist
    Age:

    #177284   2008-05-20 01:35 GMT      

    pricklycharacter

    Members


    Online status

    361 posts

    Location: Burundi
    Occupation: Film producer
    Age:

    #177285   2008-05-20 01:46 GMT      
    They are both among the hardest fields in general. It really depends what you are better at. ME takes a lot more intuition about how objects interact while EE takes more ability to think abstractly.

    Kea

    Members


    Online status

    353 posts

    Location: Liberia
    Occupation: Furrier
    Age:

    #177286   2008-05-20 01:47 GMT      
    One must have the propensity for the disciple to achieve the goal,,,not many mechanical guys like electrical and ..not many electrical guys like mechanical...I would say that to become a good electrical engineer one "MUST" understand the mechanics...but the opposite may not be true...Since i am the Electrical guy ...Of course Electrical is tougher...ho ho ho.....From the E

    Shrouded

    Members


    Online status

    384 posts

    Location: Bouvet Island
    Occupation: Dictator
    Age:

    #177287   2008-05-20 02:20 GMT      
    I'm a computer engineer, which is a subset of electrical. I've worked with making robots, so I've gotten to see the different skill sets in use for mechanical and electrical though. My take is this, for standard purposes- each type highlights different skills.

    Electrical - Needs a strong calculus background. Needs some computer programming skills. Has to be able to work with abstract simulations with of numbers of simple but complexly interacting parts (i.e. A million capacitors and resistors). For hands on things, may need to solder or connect up wires.

    Mechanical - Needs a strong simultaneous equation solving background. Needs a good memory for material types and components. Has to be able to work with CAD type programs to design parts. Simulations will generally have less numbers of parts, with less interconnections, but with a much larger number of standard and custom parts (i.e. a dozen different custom valves and pumps). For hands on things, may need machine shop skills.

    The hands on stuff is not so important when you get a real job, as most companies are happy to pay you to do desk work and design- while paying someone less money to do the assembly and fabrication (either in-house or in another country). For both, the math and simulation skills are very important. I would say a big difference between them is that in mechanical engineering- you need to remember a lot more. There are a ton of possible materials and parts, with a ton of different factors. Weight, strength, conductivity (in a bunch of forms), shape, etc all need to be worked out properly for a full system to work right.

    An electrical system simply doesn't have any many types of components for most purposes. RLC (resistor, inductor, capacitor) circuits comprise many of the analog systems in the world. Semi-conductor gates comprise most of the digital electronics, in a bunch of different forms. However, electrical systems can end up with absurd numbers of parts.

    If choosing between them, for both you need math- and lots of it. Your math and your computer design/simulation skills will determine your career. For choosing between them, I would say EE if you like "Billions of relatively simple and uniform parts" or ME if you like "Thousands of parts, but not necessarily simple ones"

    TochaTocha

    Members


    Online status

    325 posts

    Location: Guyana
    Occupation: Bellman
    Age:

    #177288   2008-05-20 02:29 GMT      
    both are harder but when compared mechanical is bit easy of u want to have a clear cut information about this u can visit the anna university website and u can check out the syallabus then u can judge which is better for any ways all the best
    > 1 <
    Categories: Tenant Screening Declutter your Home List Building Decorate Your Home Porches Decks How to Start Your Own Cellar Kitchen Care Home Inspection Boo-Boos Paint Tips For Your Home Bathroom Accessories Waterfront Property Air Purifiers Vacuum Cleaners Waterfront Property Swimming Pools Sell Your House Roofing Power Tools Energy Efficient Home Excavation Equipment Metal Detector Alternative Energy Ceiling Fans Mini Blinds Home Security Excavation Equipment Home Improvement Carpet Pool Accessories Carport Home Makeover Lighting Construction Management Windows Water Treatment Solar Energy Shipping Security Roofing Remodeling Patio Mattress Home Refinancing Home Inspector Home DIY Generators Garage Remodeling Excavation Machines Chandelier Bathroom Accessories Alarm Systems Woodworking Termites Siding Rugs Home Security Realtor Real Estate Moving Relocation Window Blinds Kitchen Remodeling Flooring Buying A New Home